|
LSD, Alcoholism and Transcendence
CHARLES SAVAGE, M.D.
from: LSD, the
Consciousness-Expanding Drug ©1964 David Solomon
"Visit either you like: they're both
mad."
"But I don't want to go among mad
people," Alice remarked.
"Oh, you can't help that," said the Cat.
"We're all mad here. I'm mad. You're
mad."
"How do you know I'm mad?" said Alice.
"You must be," said the Cat, "or you
wouldn't have come here."
The Cat recognized what was not apparent to his Victorian
contemporaries. We are all part of a sick society, troubled
members of a troubled world. Inevitably many people look to drink
for salvation. For some it is an imperfect salvation, leading to
the couch, the hospital or the grave.
Our plight is not unlike that of the
nineteenth-century American Indian. His land was stolen, his
livelihood lost, his life forfeit, his language, customs and
beliefs were all deliberately undermined by the white man in the
name of Christ, Culture and Civilization. Confronted with
physical and spiritual annihilation, the "red man"
faced the future with grim foreboding. Many Indians turned to
drink; but others turned to peyote, the Aztec counterpart of LSD.
Seemingly they turned to peyote for inner strength. "Peyote
gave them faith in a new power and a new road that they might
follow from the path that was still in their hearts and mind to a
feared and little understood future. The meeting of compelling
forces, conscious and unconscious, of racial memories, the loss
of tribal security and religious beliefs, added to the drive of
the creative urge to make live in form and color the spirit of
the Indian" (26).8
Slotkin (24) has reported that peyote has
remarkable physiological and psychological characteristics so
that when taken under proper conditions, the worshiper
experiences a revelation. In most cases this takes the form of a
vision. In some cases, it is a mystical state, the unification of
all immediate experience with "God."
The connection of peyote and LSD is not only in
their psychophysiological properties; it happens also that both
have been and are used in the treatment of alcoholism. As early
as 1907 anthropologists (24) had reported that peyote was a cure
for alcoholism; and in 1909 it was reported of the Winnebagos
that of the degenerate drunks of thirty years ago (1879), those
who had turned to peyote had now become the most successful,
healthy and outstanding members of the Winnebago community.9
Today (1960) recovery rates as high as 70 percent
are being reported with the LSD therapy of alcoholics.10 Rather than
attempt a critical evaluation of these claims, I propose to deal
here with the question: How may LSD be of help to the alcoholic?
Long ago William James (14) made the comment:
"The cure for dipsomania is religomania."
James quoted the following example from a drunkard,
S. H. Hadley: "One Tuesday evening, I sat in a saloon in
Harlem, a homeless, friendless dying drunkard. I had pawned and
sold everything that would bring a drink. I could not sleep
unless I was dead drunk. I had not eaten for days, and for four
nights preceding I had suffered with delirium tremens or the
horrors from midnight until morning. I often said, 'I will never
be a tramp. I will find a home in the bottom of the river.' But
the Lord so ordered it that when the time did come, I was not
able to walk one quarter of the way to the river. As I sat there
thinking, I seemed to feel some great and mighty presence. I did
not know then what it was. I did learn afterwards that it was
Jesus, the sinners' friend. I walked up to the bar and pounded it
with my fist 'til I made the glasses rattle. Those who stood by
drinking looked on with scornful curiosity. I said I would never
take another drink if I died in the street." And so complete
was Hadley's conversion that he never did take another drink. As
an example of a conversion reaction with LSD followed by
abstinence: An alcoholic woman was given 150 micrograms of LSD;
during her session she fell silent. She closed her eyes and
seemed to fall into a trance. She woke with a start, and said:
"I thought I had been killed. I thought I was tried, dragged
in chains before God, condemned and taken out to be
executed." She awoke feeling that she had been reprieved,
that she had been saved.11
Another patient had had doses of 100 to 200
micrograms of LSD without noticeable benefit. She laughed and
danced and listened to jazz records. She once described that she
had talked with the devil and had thrown in her lot with him. So
she went the devil's way, increasing her drinking and taking
"dope." Her final session was with 500 micrograms. She
talked to the devil and told him: "Look, I tried it your way
and what has it got me?" She then had the feeling that
"God" reached out his hand to her, and she was debating
whether or not to grasp it. Following this experience, the
patient seemed to be in a psychotic or depersonalized state,
became very depressed and planned suicide. She wrote a suicide
note in the midst of which she fell asleep, awoke in the morning
and found she was still alive. The last word she had written in
her suicide note was "church" and she thought perhaps a
miracle had occurred.
This patient's experience also illustrates the need
for careful aftercare in order to prevent suicide and psychosis.12
James' explanation of such experiences is
compelling: "The difference between a sudden and a gradual
convert is not necessarily the presence of a divine miracle in
the case of one and of something less divine in that of the
other, but rather a simple psychological peculiarity, the fact
that in the recipient of the more instantaneous grace we have one
of those subjects who are in possession of a large region in
which mental work can go on subliminally and from which invasive
experiences abruptly upsetting the equilibrium of the primary
consciousness may come."
Some of these patients (treated with LSD) equate
forgiveness of sins with healing. The relentless conscience has
relented and now the patient is freed of guilt: Thus the old
cycle of drink to still guilt, and drink giving rise to guilt, is
broken. With the slate wiped clean, the patient is free to deal
with the guilt of the moment rather than the guilt of the
accumulated years. Borrowing from analytic metapsychology we
might say the unconscious superego has become conscious, though
it is still projected onto God rather than recognized as part of
the self. Made conscious, it has lost some of its minatory
quality.13
The conversion reaction is only one type of
spiritual experience which might lead to recovery from
alcoholism; but there is still another and more basic one: the
mystic experience. James has suggested that one of the
motivations for drinking is to achieve an actual mystic
experience:
"The sway of alcohol over mankind is
unquestionably due to its power to stimulate the mystical
faculties of human nature, usually crushed to earth by the cold
facts and dry criticisms of the sober hour. Sobriety diminishes,
discriminates and says No. Drunkenness expands, unites, and says
Yes. It is in fact the great exciter of the Yes function in man.
It brings its votary from the chill periphery of things to the
radiant core. It makes him for the moment one with truth. Not
through perversity do men run after it. To the poor and
unlettered it stands in the place of symphony concerts and of
literature; it is part of the deeper mystery and tragedy of life
that whiffs and gleams of something that we immediately recognize
as excellent should be vouchsafed to so many of us only in the
fleeting earlier phases of what in its totality is so degrading a
poison. The drunken consciousness is one bit of the mystic
consciousness and our total opinion of it must find its place in
our opinion of that larger whole." A long-shoreman put it
more simply: "If it weren't for whiskey, a poor man would
never know how a rich man feels."
What, then, is the need for this mystic experience
or the transcendental experience? I believe that Fromm has given
us the answer. The alcoholic suffers from alienation, from the
"sickness of the soul." All that has been worthwhile in
him has been projected onto the outer world, whether it be God or
manna. All that is base is retained within himself. "What is
his problem? Is it his drinking or is his drinking only a symptom
of his real problem, his failure to live a meaningful life? Can
man live with this degree of alienation from himself with so much
hate and so little love without feeling inferior and
disturbed?" (12).
An illustration of this appeared in Life
sometime ago (1959) under the ironic title "The Good
Life." The people therein portrayed are so discontented with
themselves that they are continually racing after power saws,
power motors, power boats. They cannot stand being with
themselves for a moment. They are alienated from themselves,
alienated from their universe. Their transcendental or creative
function is entirely blocked. Compare them with Wordsworth:
Nuns fret not at their convent's narrow room;
And hermits are contented with their cells;
And students with their pensive citadels:
Maids at the wheel, the weaver at his loom,
Sit blithe and happy; bees that soar for bloom,
High as the highest Peak of Furness Fells,
Will murmur by the hour in foxglove bells:
In truth, the prison, unto which we doom
Ourselves, no prison is:
Unlike Wordsworth's ideal, modern man is so completely
imprisoned and alienated that for him the happy idle hours become
a rat race, and the time waster spans his weekend with drink.
Many drinkers drink because their lives have lost purpose and
meaning. The old drunk might drown his sorrows; the modern drunk
fills the emptiness of his existence.
The alcoholic attempts to find himself, to fulfill
himself with drink; but the attempt fails and now the guilt over
drink and the wasted opportunity has him trapped. How then may
LSD help with this situation? It may provide a genuine
transcendental or mystic experience instead of the spurious one
"bit of mystic consciousness" which the alcoholic has
been seeking. The artificial distinction between subject and
object, self and world, conscious and unconscious, ego, id and
superego are all abolished. The person is at one with the
universe. In his mystic selflessness he awakens with a feeling of
rebirth, often physically felt, and he is provided with a new
beginning, a new sense of values. He becomes aware of the
richness of the unconscious at his disposal; the energies bound
up in and by repression become available to him.
One patient during LSD was drawn into a mystic
experience by the sound of a floor buffer turning round and round
in the passageway. She was drawn into a mystic participation with
the writer and with God. Yet she struggled for her individuality,
even as Jacob wrestled with the Angel. Afterwards she said:
"I recognized after this that I was strong, that I didn't
need to be afraid, that I didn't need to drink." She and her
husband had been refractory members of Alcoholics Anonymous for
years. Now that she has stopped drinking the husband has started
again.14
What happens when we seek transcendence with LSD?
Once we open Pandora's box, we cannot always control what flies
out. The LSD experience may strip the patient of his capacity for
lies and rationalization; he may see himself in all his
psychological nakedness. To expose him so violently and suddenly
to his shortcomings may only increase his guilt to an intolerable
degree and leave him very depressed. He should, one would think,
have at least some "glimpse of heaven" if he is to be
"saved." Some inner strength, some hope, some
creativity and some positive feelings must be revealed to him.
This brings us forcibly to the dangers of LSD
treatment. The transcendental experience may open up avenues of
creativity but it is not creativity itself; the experience of
revelation while present may lead the person to confuse fantasy
with actual achievement. Unless the constructive aspects of the
experience are sufficiently stressed, the individual may not have
the strength to face himself stripped of all his rationalizations
and projections, a "herring lying in the gutter" (2).
Therefore, unless he has some awareness of "God's"
mercy, unless he can come to terms with himself as through the
mystic experience, and unless he develops new and free energy
from the unconscious to alter his life situation, he may develop
not only a depression but a frankly paranoid reaction. The
intervention of the therapist makes the difference between a
helpful and a damaging experience. The therapist need arrogate no
religious attributes to himself; indeed he must resist the
temptation to believe in the omnipotent role in which he has been
placed. For if he does not, he will then reinforce, rather than
alleviate the pathological alienation which he is striving to
overcome.
There is another danger which is shared with the
peyotists. For years government experts and anthropologists have
been warring as to whether peyote is or is not harmful. In point
of fact the writer has been able to find authentic evidence of
only one peyote psychosis, this on a brief personal visit to the
Navajo reservation. But the circumstances are instructive. This
was a young man who had branched out on his own. He had his own
private stock of peyote which he was nipping on the side, instead
of taking it during the highly formalized peyote ritual. 15 In the
same manner self-experimentation with LSD is clearly dangerous.
LSD strips off the protective barriers of the ego and all
sensitivity and perceptivity is heightened. The effect of any
input is heightened, so that the drug has great potential for
good and evil. It is possible to induce or reinforce unusual
beliefs which may alienate the individual from his society at a
time when he desperately needs it.
Finally, LSD causes an inflation of the ego which
may be an effective antidote for low self-esteem. Low
self-esteem, of course, has many roots. All Good is projected
onto God; all Bad is retained in the form of original sin within
oneself. There are other problems that derive from the Protestant
ethic. There is the stress on the outward evidence of grace as
seen by visible evidence of prosperity, the stress on social
mobility, the existential guilt arising from the fact that few
reach their actual potential: all this adds up to a sort of mass,
low self-esteem, a cosmic sense of inferiority, which is actually
increased by material achievement and accession of material
goods. Ordinary psychotherapy brings out a person's shortcomings
and not his assets. But LSD allows a person to face his
shortcomings with honesty, and at the same time experience some
of the wealth and reservoirs which lie within him. We can perhaps
promise that the Mute Inglorious Milton experience the raptures
felt by Milton, even if he cannot write his poetry.
We should also recall that Vergil guided Dante into
the Inferno and returned him safely, chastened and enlightened.
Those who would use LSD should do as well for their patients.
Case History of Excessive Drinking with Improvement
Following LSD
This was a 30-year-old radiologist who consulted
the writer in 1959. He complained that for the past year he had
nightly drunk himself to sleep, and then awoke with nightmares in
the middle of the night. His wife would become enraged at being
awakened and he would spend the rest of the night crying. He was
depressed, unable to work. However, his chief complaint, of years
duration, was an inability to feel or experience. "It was as
if I was inside a glass shell. I mean I could see out and people
could see in, but I couldn't talk or feel."
The patient was an only child, whose mother had
died when he was an infant. He was raised by foster parents until
the age of four and then repossessed by father and stepmother.
His relations with them were distant. His father reportedly
insisted on high standards of intellectual performance, always
blamed, never rewarded or praised. Raised as a strict Catholic,
the patient married out of the Church and was cut off by his
family. He abandoned the Church but it made little difference: as
he expressed it: "When I was on a religious kick, it was
'I'm a sinner'; and essentially now it's 'I'm a neurotic.'"
His purgatory was in effect merely moved from the future into the
present. Alienated from God, nature, man, church, mother and
family, he tried for reconciliation by conquering. His friends he
subdued with words, his patients with his X-rays, and the
universe with his theories. Only once in his life had he overcome
his alienation. During sexual relations with his secretary, out
in the moonlight, he felt "At that instant I had contacted
the universe." He hoped for a repetition of this with his
wife, and had the unwisdom to tell her about it on their
honeymoon. But he felt nothing for her, could not love her. To
add to their misery she became pregnant and he had a psychotic
breakdown. She aborted but never forgave, never forgot nor
allowed him to forget. He wanted a reconciliation but his efforts
to force it only estranged them further. The patient said that he
had taken to drink to recapture the experience, but it failed.
Psychotherapy seemed futile; words were used as
hostile ammunition and playthings; he fielded each interpretation
perfectly and returned the appropriate riposte, for he had read
and was well versed in Freud, Jung and Watts. Yet when he left
the hour, he had forgotten everything. It was the patient's
suggestion that LSD be tried, which was done after fourteen
preliminary psychotherapeutic interviews.
He began the session by using the drug as a
platform to preach his private philosophy. "So anyway this
sort of thing, Goedel's proof, the Heisenberg principle of
indeterminacy, the insolubility of any mechanical problem that
contains more than two bodies by a method of other than
successive approximation.... There's me sub one and me sub two
and me sub one gets in the way of me sub two."
In order to turn off this stream and direct him
inward we tried some abstract paintings and then Bruckner.
"Anyway I'd like to hear a little Bruckner now. Oceanic
feelings. Da dum da da dum. That is what Bach did for a living,
Bach did for kicks."
Bruckner's music was an effective stimulus: the
patient became ill and then suddenly experienced the nightmare of
which he had complained. He shook with fear, trembled and sobbed:
"I'm afraid, I'm afraid. I keep looking; there is nothing
there; what am I afraid of?" I replied: "Perhaps that's
what you are afraid of: nothing." With this the nightmare
disappeared, and years later the patient reported that it had
never returned. At that moment he reported a mystic
enlightenment, a kind of satori. He experienced feeling,
closeness with the therapist, with himself and the universe (and,
after the session, with his wife). In the evening he telephoned
to tell me how grateful he was. He had experienced completely
successful sexual relations for the first time. He began to pour
his energy into his work, and nightly drinking sessions were no
longer required.
To the therapist he seemed profoundly changed, and
for the better. His wife, on the contrary, became much upset,
bitter, angry and depressed. She reminded the patient
continuously: "You're no different; besides it won't last;
you'll see." A self-fulfilling prophecy. We thought to
rectify the situation by repeating the LSD experience with the
patient, by giving the wife an LSD experience, and then arranging
a joint LSD session. The first two were accomplished, but not the
third. She refused, saying it was a terrible experience. (During
the LSD the observer would have thought she was having a
delightful experience.) Eighteen months of intensive conjoint
family therapy were required before she could accept the
possibility of his being well.
Three years after the first consultation we learned
that he was a professor of radiology at a leading university; and
the couple was happily expecting a baby.
Footnotes
8. Monroe Tsa Toke, from whom
this quotation is taken, has done paintings which are
unquestionably the best illustration of the Peyote ritually and
the peyote visions. (back)
9. A controversy still rages
about peyote and its value for alcoholism. Slotkin quotes Hensley
[1908] with approval: Jilt [peyote] cures us of our temporal ills
as well as those of a spiritual nature. It takes away the desire
for strong drink I myself have been cured of a loathsome disease
too horrible to mention. so have hundreds of others. Hundreds of
drunkards have been dragged from their downward way. La Barrel
however, is cynical about the antagonism of alcohol and peyote.
"One can eat lobsters one day and ice cream the next, but
one ought not eat them the same day (15)." Radinss Crashing
Thunder (19) gives an eloquent account of his cure of chronic
alcoholism with delirium tremens by the use of peyote. Radin
himself remained skeptical.
"So completely did all those who joined the
peyote cult give up drinking that many Indians and whites were at
first inclined to believe that this was a direct effect of the
peyote. However, this is an error. The correct explanation is
that John Rave, the leader of the cult, gave up drinking when he
became a convert and included this renunciation of all liquors in
the cult which he so largely moulded and dominated. If any
additional proof were needed it can be found in the fact that as
Rave's personal influence decreased and as the membership
increased the number of people who drank liquor and ate peyote at
the same time increased." But Radin overlooks the fact that
John Rave gave up drinking because of peyote! (back)
10. The figure of 70 percent
is taken from Hoffer (2) and covers a five-year period, The data
on which the present paper is based, however, derive from a
series of 20 hospitalized alcoholics (in addition to the M.R.I.
patients). They were treated in the same manner described by
Terrill except the dosage ranged from 150 to 500 micrograms.
Fifty percent had stopped drinking at the time of this symposium.
Unfortunately follow-ups could not be obtained. (back)
11. Following this experience
she stopped drinking, became interested in psychotherapy and I
referred both her and her husband to a psychiatrist. He was an
ex-alcoholic who had a spontaneous religious conversion and he
insisted hers was synthetic and not genuine, Three years later he
finally proved his point. My sympathies are somewhat with her.
After listening to him on the phone for long periods in the late
evening I have often found a drink very soothing. (back)
12. After a period of
accelerated drinking, dope taking and dalliance, this patient
straightened out, returned to the church, and according to last
report (1961) had made a good adjustment for two years. (back)
13. The mere evocation of the
superego into conscious form is not in itself curative. It occurs
in terrifying fashion in delirium tremens, and can occur in
terrifying fashion with LSD. In the writer's opinion it is the
support of the therapist and his ability to maintain contact with
the patient that makes the difference in the outcome. (back)
14. She has since found it
prudent to bolster her new found strength with antabuse, to
counteract her husband's importuning her to drink. (back)
15. The writer has found that
warnings against self-experimentation (22) are ineffective: it is
like telling children not to put beans up their noses. (back)
|